CLICK HERE FOR BLOGGER TEMPLATES AND MYSPACE LAYOUTS »

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

A Worn Path

6. In answer to a student who wrote to ask her "Is the grandson really dead?" Welty responded, "My best answer would be: Phoenix is alive." What might have led the student to ask that question? How can the author's remark be seen as an answer?

The student might have believed the grandson was dead from the conversation that occurred between Phoenix and the nurse. The nurse asks the grandmother how the boy is? Phoenix continues to be occupied with other things and hesitates to answer. The nurse then replies "He isn't dead is he?" Something flickers across Phoenix face but she sort of changes the topic to how she had forgotten why she had made the long trip. This short conversation could lead the reader to believe that the grandson is dead.
The author's answer, on the other hand, I think suggests that the boy is still alive. I think it is because the grandson is still living that the grandmother herself is still alive. He gives her a reason for her life, and for her journey into the town. It is as if the journey into town is symbolic to her life as a whole.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

WOW just what I was looking for. Came here by searching for significance

Stop by my weblog - vigrx plus side effects yahoo answers

Anonymous said...

thanks, this really works:)

Here is my web site ... dental pro 7 price

Anonymous said...

Sorry hit enter ahead of I wrote the rest =D Dude you have a lot more of
the deal with around the social networking issue than
any individual I've ever read. There is like 4 PhD's really worth of content material alone in this one particular blog submit.
............!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!!

Here is my web-site attract women

Anonymous said...

I'm a molecular biologist as well as the fundamental biochemistry behind the components. Following all, within a wholesome diet, you may require these amino acids in much less concentrated forms. Hence, none of this is foreign to your body and also you are just consuming a lot more of what your muscle tissues need to have in the course of a workout. It will be reasonable to assume therefore that noxide is likely not habit forming.

my weblog six pack shortcuts workout plan pdf

Anonymous said...

I believed it experienced a shutter button?

My site - premature ejaculation cure indian medicine

Anonymous said...

I never wore maternity pants, I had a gastric bypass so I couldn't consume the sugary crap, I ate a meal for my check, I'd a
higher risk being pregnant so together with the ultrasounds every single week I just hoped they'd tell me my infant was regular, generating a baby registry was cumbersome and barely anybody that purchased me something used the registry, I never ever needed an elastic band for my trousers, I did not toss up but I had been really nauseous for like the very first 5 months and my pregnancy check seemed just just like the best one...obviously I took teo because I did not think the initial one.

Feel free to surf to my blog post; how to attract women online

Anonymous said...

Do you feel dietary epidemiology is even worthless to establish hypotheses to test with
controlled experiments? I consider it is helpful for
this, but useless as evidence.

Also visit my web site; how to eat healthy at mcdonalds